26 December, 2020

mrgoodsound's Alternative Audio Wisdom for 2021

By mrgoodsound

I am not sure if I am old enough yet to be considered wise but if we treat years spent towards the pursuit of good sound as dog years then I should be about 35 in audiophile years - married with children and chipping away at a mortgage.

My Christmas night was spent listening to spiritual jazz from the greats - Sun Ra, Mingus, Coleman, Don Cherry and of course Coltrane. Having just shaved my head (I avoid the barber due to COVID), I was feeling especially monk-like and engaged in a year-end reflection. I know this has not been a great year for many people, I am very fortunate to say it has not been that bad for me, but in terms of audio and music it was in many ways a great one.

Here are just a few audio milestones for 2020, in no particular order:

1. Acquisition of Klipsch La Scala loudspeakers

I acquired a 1970s pair of La Scala's early in the year, by chance not so long after this home visit where I heard them for the first time. I love these speakers, to do better I would have to DIY a horn system using higher quality drivers at great expense - and even then I am not sure I could match the greatness of the folded bass horn in a DIY endeavor. 

A turnkey, fully horn-loaded speaker system, available at used prices well below the retail cost of modern bookshelf speakers. If you have the space to support these speakers you will be rewarded with high-efficiency (in the true sense of the term) sound, where amplifier choice becomes a matter of taste, not requirement.

2. Converting 1s and 0s using NOS (non-oversampling) multibit DACs

Technically, I had already started becoming interested in NOS DACs in 2019, but it was not until this year that I realized their full potential. Having spent the better part of the last 3 years churning through over 20 digital audio converters priced from $100 to $2500, I actively avoided NOS DACs due to sonic descriptions from others indicating these DACs were overly warm, rolled-off, soft, etc. The irony was that these same people were recommending the 20 or so other DACs I tried and found unsatisfactory. 

After some encouraging experiments with NOS, I went out on a limb and purchased the DAC2.2SE from Ukranian manufacturer abbasaudio. I have not done a formal review of this DAC anywhere and don't plan to. I will just say this is the DAC that has made me stop thinking about DACs. It's renders music from digital sources well enough to make me cry. That's good enough for me.

3. Mono mia! (Telefunken Opus 6 Röhrenradio)

This year I gained an exponential interest in monophonic (single channel) playback, spurred on by an ever-involving interest in historical monophonic recordings. Articles such as "Mono Mia" by Vincent Gallo (pub. Sound Practices Issue #1, 1992) and "Стерео или моно" by Anatoly Likhnitsky (pub. 2001) got me thinking about home sound reproduction in a completely different way. 

I began experimenting with listening to a single speaker (for appropriate recordings), and eventually purchased a Telefunken Opus 6 radio receiver. This fine mono radio from 1956 has 6 speaker units and was carefully engineered to completely fill a room with glowing, glorious music like I have never experienced before. 

There is nothing quite like listening to a late-night classical or jazz FM broadcast on a set like this - it has opened my eyes and inspired me to attempt to achieve the same quality of sound in a full-range high-fidelity system, though I believe I am still quite a ways off from accomplishing that.

4. An expanded musical consciousness

Victories in other audio departments such as the 3 listed above have afforded me the ability to expand my musical consciousness and taste at an exponential rate. In 2019, I listened mainly to rock music, with only a cursory and surface level interest in jazz and classical. Just a year later, I can truly say I am 'into' jazz, classical, oldies, folk and even foreign artists. The discovery of new music has become something as natural and effortless as breathing, enabled by an audio system that not only satisfies but allows me to relish the aesthetics of different genres, recording eras and musical consciousnesses. 

Most of my digital listening is done now on YouTube, where Google's extremely powerful algorithm has a never-ending hole of increasingly obscure recommendations to make. I have subscriptions to many small-time channels whose owners take time to upload rare recordings and performances, including the delicate digitization's of LP and shellac records. The ability to sample a lifetimes worth of music before purchasing a physical copy is a true modern-day blessing.

5. Letting go of audio pretenses & pretentiousness

I use the term 'pretense' here as a polite way of saying bullsh**. 

Bullsh** like:

  • caring what anyone else thinks about your system
  • the audio tribalism and groupthink present consciously and unconsciously in so many aspects of this hobby
  • the meandering and meaningless arguments that take place in so many audio discussion groups and forums
  • what dogmas the 'audio scientists' have to proclaim as false shepherds about what is and is not possible in sound reproduction
  • most of all what those who do not even understand or appreciate music (though they are often the loudest to proclaim that they do) have to say about anything audio-related.

Forget them all. The ability to see through such noise and remained focus with acute perception on what matters most to you will be the most useful tool in achieving aural nirvana and good sound. I say this as someone who is now achieving one audio success after another, only after completely discarding such pretenses and pretentiousness. 

I suggest to ignore anyone who provides you advice without asking and understanding first: what music do you enjoy? what sounds do you like to hear? what sacrifices are you willing to make? These questions form the basis of your aural matrix, and let you pick and choose system components that fit inside of it.

I suggest to not ask even a wise master for advice if you do not have the answers to these questions. It will only lead to disappointment and a sure path to audio hell. 

I suggest to keep around some form of inexpensive system which is capable of providing musical satisfaction: equipment which allows you to enjoy the music you have while finding more, equipment in which your engagement with it remains utterly non-cerebral. It may be a cheap receiver you inherited from a family member, a $20 CD player you found at a thrift store, and speakers you rescued from a dumpster. The less pretentious, the better. 

Assembled, these components will become your sanity control, something to fall back on if you take too many steps on the wrong path in the pursuit of aural nirvana. The one time this pursuit becomes truly dangerous is if the soul & spirit are denied the nourishment of music for an extended period of time, generally from having an expensive system you don't feel like listening to. This is what causes burn-out and audio depression. You have been warned!

Sources of alternative audio wisdom

If you are ready to or are already in the process of rejecting mainstream audio ideology, here are some sites which may provide nice reading material during the holiday break.

The Triode Guild - this website contains articles and publications of the late Dr. Harvey 'Gizmo' Rosenberg. As the name suggests, most of the articles are about vacuum tube amplification, but Rosenberg was a truly hilarious and entertaining writer regarding any subject. I burst out laughing more than once reading articles such as Sex, Music, and Pentodes.

Arthur Salvatore's Audio Critique - this website contains articles and essays of Arthur Salvatore, a lifelong audiophile who shares information on audio philosophy, audio components and the high-end audio industry. I do not expressly agree with all of the opinions on this website, but I would especially implore readers to carefully review the sections of the website detailing the escapades of the audio press and review magazines. The insight is invaluable.

Sound Practices - a magazine published in the 1990s as part of the underground American audio scene, consider it a sort of counter-culture to Stereophile and TAS. Many articles have been republished online though I recommend paying for the entire archive here. The fact that information in articles which are nearly three decades old are still so relevant today show how little forwards progress there is in the audio industry.

Nutshell High Fidelity - the home page of Lynn Olson, containing many well-written and insightful articles on tube amplifiers, loudspeaker design and DIY. Especially recommended is A Tiny History of High Fidelity.

AML - the home page of the late Russian audio engineer Anatoly Likhnitsky. Only a few articles were translated to English but the site can be easily understood using Google Translate. Likhnitsky thinks more deeply and clearly about audio reproduction than anyone else I have ever encountered. He has a cult following of sorts in the East, and some Western admirers as well, including Peter Qvortup of Audio Note UK. Especially recommended to read his article on the death of high-end audio.

With all that said, I leave you with a beautiful tune to relax to as we close out this year. I wish all readers a happy holiday break and much audio success in 2021!


19 comments:

  1. Great post and congratulations on escaping from the eternal inferno of HIFI GAS bases sely on commercial principle!
    Merry Christmas and stay safe!

    ReplyDelete
  2. very nice article...I espec. agree about Dac part. Btw i also use Abbas dac just "plain" 2.2 which is after 50 days of traveling (and customs) finally in my home (like a Santa gift)and last few days it slowly "break in" and already it sound really,really well...But i will use this to wish all the best wishes to all of you who contributing to this site which for me is one of best ones...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for your comment and congratulations on your new DAC. I hope it brings you many hours of listening pleasure

      Delete
  3. Byw, I have been using the Sparkler cdp with NOS DAC for years and am extremely happy with the sound. Also recent purchase of the Lite AH DAC using 4xTD1543 per channel as NOS was loaned ro my friend Kwong and immediately implanted into his rig n has no intention to give it back to me, hahaha.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Simply the best audio article I've read for 2020. Thanks, particularly like your part on "Letting go of audio pretenses & pretentiousness" and "Sources of alternative audio wisdom".

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Down with the authorities! ... what a wonderful line (though a list of recommended alternative authorities immediately follows) ...)))
      Bad luck, unlike the author - I met Sergey Abbas at an audio show of Russian manufacturers (it would be more correct to call them DIY) - a muddy sound (only suitable for mp3 and bright acoustics), aggressive marketing - made a repulsive impression.
      I was at Likhnitsky's house (I bought a CD digitized by Vera Briner) ... I saw his system (done with an ax) ... I asked a couple of questions and when he "suffered" about what golden ears he has, how many records he listened to as a child - I felt like a fool and a failure ... I was deprived of such miracles in my childhood ... or rather, it was different - my grandfather was the director of one of the world's best philharmonic societies and for several years I was forcibly taken to rehearsals and performances by great stage masters and orchestras. .. (it's good that it's free).
      Probably his sound was more honest, but my system at that time (ATC 50 + Musical Fidelity KW series), even when turned off, brought more joy ...
      Around 1992, I owned La Scala-1 for 2 days ... my friend was desperately trying to build a quad system on these speakers, but he failed and he put up one pair for sale (I asked for a weekend ... they were tortured to carry them and move furniture) - negative impressions - this is not my sound - somewhat detached ...
      I know that you are trying to save money (I myself have become such now) and you did not ask for advice and will never accept, but I would rather find LS 3/5 and 2 subfooters (1 is placed when there is no space, 2 is always better, but the room should be more) ... 3/5 will have a flat stage, but mids! - you can forgive everything for this ... Subwoofer - pay attention to Velodyne - they have been doing just that for a very long time. (don't buy cheap at all).
      Go ahead ...
      Experiments with 1 speaker, in my opinion, were invented by those who cannot get a real stereo effect on two (this is not a joke, most often it is) ...
      The phrase about fools on the forums - indicates that you actively read them ... For example, I am not registered anywhere at all - it's strange that I stayed here ... I tried to "sow on a stone" - no, it didn't sprout (((

      Down with civilization! - I myself will invent the wheel of paper and gunpowder ... It sounds bold, but here I would have gone the other way. I think in audio you can limit yourself to Floyd Toole's lectures on electroacoustics.

      It's sad that after so many of my posts - someone listens to rock music at home ((((On the other hand, you can't go through evolution in 1 minute - in natural life it takes years (although a smart person can - just by making an effort ... but you need whoever he believes).
      By the way, jazz is a kind of "musical prostitution" - it is a lack of frames, attachments, constant attempts to try something new ...

      There was a joke in the Soviet Union: "Today you play jazz, and tomorrow you will sell your homeland" ... Surprisingly, years passed and it was these people who sold their homeland ...

      You are a terrible person! - you yourself shaved yourself bald ... I hope there are no orange clothes. A radical step - girls will not love)))

      Delete
    2. Merry Christmas greetings?
      I understand that this is a formality and most people in your society think that Christianity is a verbal moralistic teaching ...
      Want a secret? -
      This phenomenon is exclusively physical and in fact words are not needed at all ... with their help they are only trying to tell about it. This is a special mode of work of the psyche - a complete rejection of egoism!
      Western swindlers have replaced the teaching of Christ in order to manipulate people for their own purposes - they invented Protestants and Catholics ... hence the crusades and "marriages" of sexual perverts and urinals on the walls of European churches - no one appreciates this, people feel deception, there are no results, huge money in the hands of individuals ... and the teaching is full of selfishness ... look at their saints - sick people - they have hallucinations ... for example Teresa of Avila - she has an affair with Christ ... delirium.
      Now about the date of the holiday (allegory will be) ...
      Imagine 2 different sockets; green triangles run along one line like electricity, and red circles run along other wires.
      Your goal is to "get red and round" - which outlet do you plug yourself into ???
      So in life - celebrating with Catholics and Protestants - you will be like them ... EGOISTS and you will lose time for some unknown reason.
      Yes - there is another world ... everything is different there, but you have no knowledge about this and access to information ... There is almost no real Christianity left (this is very difficult) ... separate hearths on Athos, in Russia and other Orthodox countries ... The devil (consumer society) wins ...
      Look at today's youth (compare 30-40 years ago) - they can’t do anything, they don’t know anything - BUT HAVE THEIR OPINION ABOUT EVERYTHING.
      On this joyful note, I end ... Whoever has a silver landau - fold the top, find a deserted road, drink beer, slippers on the floor and this song at full volume (chorus - my grandmother smokes a pipe - my grandmother smokes a pipe) ...

      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7H5VSwrckcI

      Delete
    3. Thanks for your comment icefox and I am glad you enjoyed it.

      to our Anonymous friend: LOL, I hope one day I can meet you and shake your hand. you write comedy gold. I will only address this point: "Down with the authorities! ... what a wonderful line (though a list of recommended alternative authorities immediately follows) ...)))"

      I hope the astute reader can realize the difference for his or herself between a recommendation of authority and just another independent source of information to broaden ones own horizons. Exposure to more independent sources of information are of course the only way to become one's own authority and one's own guru. I think even you realize this and are just giving me a hard time 8)

      Delete
  5. mrgoodsound -
    Thanks for sharing your story and your thoughts. It's funny but what you wrote in your *alternative sources of wisdom* - well, it's almost exactly what I had thought I might write up and post somewhere. I think you are spot on. And the sources you refer to are the ones I have been reading, too. I always got a big kick out of Harvey Rosenberg and was saddened when he passed from this earth. It was in the last few months that I ran across Lynn Olson and I think his writing is original and insightful.

    Also a bit interesting is that you chose to go with Abbas Audio, as I too, was strongly considering one of his DACs but ended up going with the MHDT Labs Orchid.

    I enjoy this blog a great deal. Thanks Doctorjohn & all the others who post here.

    Warmest regards

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for your comment. It seems you have good taste!

      Delete
  6. Brilliant article by a bald man! :-) I am listening to my HK "leftovers". Right now a lowly Philips AK601 that I bought many years ago for HKD 50 (less than USD 7).

    Enjoy the music! As the bald man says, know your preferences before asking questions!

    mrgoodsound's articles are always a surprise, kind of a blitzkrieg, appearing when one least expects. Keep up the good work!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Aaaah, the mesmerizing Julie Christie!

      Delete
  7. Great post. Special thanks for the AML links. never heard before of this interesting figure.
    I second heartily your SP recommendation. Joe Roberts was one of the best editors in the audio world before going back to sales business with Silbatone. What was unique to SP was the attitude. Almost everyone else makes audio look like a nerd-only business. SP was the opposite. It made audio almost hip. A bunch of new yorkers deserve great credit for that too. Read Herb Reichert, Vincent Gallo (yes, the movie star, he's a singer and musician - and very inspired at that - and an audiophile, great advocate of Western Electric sound and mono listening). My favorite writer was JC Morrison - now super-high-end tube amp designer for Silbatone - always a fun read and he gave very unusual music recommendations (Alessandro Moreschi!). They had *style* and *inspiration*. They communicated the idea that audio is one of the joys of life. And that you can be bohemian and audiophile at the same time. I think this is a major contribution, much more than recommending the right value of plate resistors for triode driver stages in my book, YMMV.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for your comment. I agree, the coolness just bleeds off of the pages of this mag.

      Delete
  8. Talking about Joe Roberts, there is this crazy thread where he "exchanged" with the hot-headed Romy the Cat:

    http://www.goodsoundclub.com/Forums/ShowPost.aspx?PageIndex=1&postID=9404#9404

    I'd suggest you only read what Roberts wrote. Romy the Cat, while sometimes OK, gives me a big headache when I try to read him. I don't anymore.

    Incidentally, dagogo's other Roberts, Jack, also has his feet on the ground.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. good stuff. audio AIDS, I think I have been diagnosed.

      I considered to add the goodsoundclub as a joke to the post but I feared people would try to take it seriously. it is my namesake after all

      Delete
    2. Great link, I did notice this one. Joe Roberts is a most effective communicator, a marketing man. You cannot say the same about Romy. Even though his ideas about audio are often not trivial. His prose is next to a nightmare. I don't know if there's a language problem involved, but he also unfortunately comes out as arrogant and unnecessarily aggressive. To a point that for me is untolerable, and that's why I would never, ever post anything not even "Hello" on that forum. I prefer quiet places full of polite people, like here. On a side note, I really appreciate the civility of this blog and the comments. It does matter. A lot.

      Delete
  9. mrgoodsound I know this is an older blog post and that over time horns have left your list of preferences. But in the rear view mirror. With the La Scalas. I'm interested to how you deployed them with you enjoyed them. Did they work for listening relatively closely or did you have to get farther away from them. They seem like an interesting option for low level bloom given their efficiency. I am wondering if they sound coherent if you sit say seven or eight feet from them in a domestic environment. I enjoyed your wisdom for audio success going into 2021.

    ReplyDelete